A hard question that deserves an honest answer rather than a one-size-fits-all recipe.
What I look at
- Can the tooth be restored afterwards and stay strong? It needs enough structure.
- The condition of the root, bone and gum around it.
- Whether a deep fracture runs into the root.
- How important the tooth is to your chewing and general health.
- Restorability
Part of assessing the options.
- Tooth condition
The illustration does not decide the treatment.
I take advice from doctors of other specialties if needed.
The other side
Extraction is not a failure, and is sometimes the right call. But replacing a tooth with an implant or bridge has its own cost and procedures and never quite matches a natural tooth. So I make decisions after careful diagnosis, not before it.
Related reading
Core treatments
Medical notice: the information here is for general health education and is not a substitute for an examination and assessment by a dentist. If you notice any symptoms or changes in your teeth or gums, even if they seem minor, do not ignore them; consult a dentist to assess them and decide whether they need treatment.